Hong Kong Woman Found Guilty of Indonesian Maid Abuse, Sentenced to Six Years in Jail

By Isaiah Narciso
Hong Kong Maid Abuse Case
Hong Kong Maid Abuse Case

In a case that has highlighted the treatment of migrant workers mainly from Indonesia and the Philippines, a Hong Kong woman has been sentenced to six years in prison for assaulting her Indonesian maid.

According to Chester Yung of the Wall Street Journal, 44-year-old Law Wan-tung was found guilty on Feb. 10 of 18 charges that ranged from assault to criminal intimidation and failure to pay wages to her maid, 25-year-old Erwiana Sulistyahingsih, and other household staff. Hong Kong District Court Judge Amanda Woodcock handed down the sentence.

"I hope my case will be a lesson to other employers not to exploit their domestic workers," Sulistyaningsih said. "We are here to help the Hong Kong economy."

Yung reported that Hong Kong law requires domestic helpers to live with their employers. The government has argued that its live-in requirement would help prevent employers from exploiting their foreign maids outside their domestic contracts.

"But advocates of foreign maids say the live-in requirement limits the freedom of the workers and makes them more vulnerable to abuses," Yung wrote.

According to the Wall Street Journal, Woodcock ordered Wan-tung to pay a fine worth 15,000 Hong Kong dollars ($1,900) in addition to handing down a prison sentence.

Hong Kong Maid Abuse Case
Hong Kong Maid Abuse Case

The BBC reported that the Indonesian maid described being beaten and starved by Wan-tung. Her plight drew international attention after she went back to Indonesia to seek treatment in hospital in December 2013. 

"She came home beaten and bruised, too weak to walk and without any money," the BBC wrote. "Her face, hands and legs were covered with scabs and lacerations. Parts of her skin were blackened and peeling."

Yung reported that Wan-tung was arrested on January 2014 before she could board a flight to Thailand at Hong Kong International Airport. He described the treatment Wan-tung practiced on the Indonesian maid.

"Law punched Ms. Sulistyaningsih and hit her with metal hangers, a ruler, a broom handle, a vacuum-cleaner tube and a ladder," Yung wrote, citing court testimony. "Sulistyaningsih was given one small bottle of drinking water each day and was fed only twice a day."

While Sulistyaningsih was happy to get justice served in Hong Kong, she told the Wall Street Journal that the six-year prison sentence was too lenient based on the nature of the crime. However, she plans to help other maids who have suffered abuse by other Hong Kong employers.

"I will go back home and continue my study," Sulistyaningsih said. "In the future, I will want to help other migrant workers if they face the similar problem like this."

According to the Wall Street Journal, more than 330,000 women, mainly from Indonesia and the Philippines, work as "helpers" in Hong Kong. Their compensation rate is usually around $530 a month, which is the government-mandated minimum wage.

  • Chinese Christian film Sight named one of the best Christian films of 2024

    The Chinese Christian-themed film Sight has been named one of the best Christian films of 2024 by Crosswalk, a North American online platform for Christian resources. The film is based on the true story of Dr. Ming Wang, chronicling his journey from a young boy navigating the harsh realities of China’s Cultural Revolution to becoming a world-renowned ophthalmologist and embarking on a journey of Christian faith.

  • Most Popular Bible Verses for Christmas

    During the Christmas season, Bible readers often turn to well-known passages from Matthew and Luke, along with selections from Isaiah and Psalms. People not only read the familiar stories of Jesus’ birth but also take time to reflect on Psalms and Old Testament prophecies.

  • Pew Report Evaluates Countries with Severe Religious Persecution: Egypt and Syria Top the List

    The Pew Research Center has released its 15th annual Global Restrictions on Religion report, highlighting the pressing challenges to religious freedom worldwide. The report identifies Egypt, Syria, Pakistan, and Iraq as the countries with the most severe restrictions on religious freedom, driven by both government limitations and societal hostility. Religious minorities in these nations face compounded pressures in practicing their faith.

  • One Malaysian Chinese Christian's Reflection on Campus Ministry and the Expanding Passion for the Gospel

    Soh Or Kan, a Malaysian Chinese Christian, looks back on his years of service in the university Christian fellowship with profound reflection. His experiences in the fellowship shaped his understanding of the Gospel mission, expanding it beyond campus boundaries to the wider community.